C++: Why can't I sort like a normal human being

Before I begin, C++ is awesome.
It's exactly the right kind of balance between low and high level languages. When you need C++, you need C++.

But it comes with it's own sets of problems.
The Standard Template Library (STL) shipped with C++ is quite great, but at the same time it's excruciating verbose and is very counter intuitive.

For instance, std::sort sorts C++ the elements in a container in place. Sounds good enough.
Now you would expect to sort like this:

  vector<int> a;
  a.push_back(1);
  a.push_back(2);
  std::sort(a);


But, NO.
std::sort would only sort over a range of elements over a container, so you must write:

  std::sort(a.begin(), a.end());

This really irritates me.
std::sort(a) would have been brilliant, easy to use, and intuitive.
I tried to pull up a simple overload and worked like a charm:

  template
  void sort(T& t)
  {
      return std::sort(t.begin(), t.end());
  }

Its one of the things that bug me as a C++ developer and HCI enthusiast.
Not overloading enough to provide simpler interfaces to your end users is simply evil and mean.


Comments

  1. UnknownMarch 2, 2013 at 6:02 AM

    I had the same issues with C++, but with networking, so I did the same and wrote a library: https://github.com/nathanpc/libinet

    C++ is a great language, but it still lacks some modern things.

    ReplyDelete
  2. ashishMarch 2, 2013 at 6:59 AM

    Exactly, we need libraries which humans can use. It's one of the fields where Java beats C++ hands down. C++11 is promising, but just if the STL was made more human-friendly, we have a long way.

    Btw, your sockets library looks quite friendly, will give it a shot when i need one!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Alarm Clock Myth - How to wake up early

Image
Everyone wants to wake up early, and make good use of those extra early morning hours. But we fail all the time, even if we succeed, its one-off times. I thought its a good opportunity to seize and fix this problem with the existing alarm clocks. I started exploring the existing solutions out there and found there are quite many interesting stuff: A whole breed of biologically sync'd clocks who wake you up when you are least in sleep Hard to snooze alarm clocks which ask you to solve a difficult puzzle to snooze an annoying alarm tone Motivational messages to wake you up I gave all the existing products a lot of thought and why they don't quite work. Here is my conclusion: People don't really understand the real purpose of alarm clocks .   Here's the deal: Alarm clocks are not meant to wake you up. Yes, you read it right. Alarm clocks really are the mission-control, last resort plan to wake you up at the deadline time. You are supposed to get up on...
Read more

Intelligent Passwords

I attempt and dare to solve the problem of password-stealing which occur primarily due to Social Engineering Hacks. Also, this adds another layer of protection over passwords and make passwords more secure and usable! The method exploits the fact that given a word to type, different people will type the word in different fashions. The speed of typing will be different and the typing-accent will vary. We now attach this typing-accent attribute to the password and make them more secure i.e. even if you tell your password to a third-person, he wont be able to authenticate himself as you. Also, this improves the usability of passwords. As pointed by Jakob Nielsen, un-masking the password would provide better usability. Passwords can now be unmasked as this method tries to cover for the social engineering hacks which are the clear threats to unmasking passwords. As a proof of concept, i provide a demo here . The demo is Javascript based, where you can set your password and then attempt to e...
Read more

The little thing that makes me hate Android

Android is awesome. We found love in a hopeless place. It's the unix of mobile phones. But it is so fricking annoying when: It vibrates on shutdown Why? Why does it have to vibrate on shutdown?? My phone battery definitely dies everyday because battery-life sucks and I suck more since I am too lazy to keep my phone charged. Now, when battery gives up, phone shuts down silently and in the end it vibrates. I pull the phone out of my pocket to see what the vibration was about, click the Power Button and it starts booting up, just to shutdown again! You may call it a dark pattern/(insert a mumbo-jumbo here), I call it wtf. wtf.
Read more